Another Taxpayer Win in The Courts For R&D Credits

Holland King | MTAX, J.D.

June 1, 2020. 3 min read

In a recent opinion, the US Tax Court rebuffed another attempt by the IRS to deny the R&D credits credit to taxpayers. By granting summary judgment to the taxpayer, the Court upheld the string of cases that define what funded research means.

The Case: Populous Holdings, Inc. v. IRS

The taxpayer, Populous Holdings, Inc. (Populous), an architectural design service company, claimed a research credit for two years; the claim included qualified research expenses associated with more than 100 client contracts. The IRS denied the credit asserting another party funded the taxpayer’s research activities in each instance. The Court reviewed a representative sample of the contracts and ultimately determined that the research was not funded, and Populous was entitled to the credit.

The Proceedings

In determining if the research performed was funded, the court followed the guidance of previous cases. In general, the courts have held that fixed-price contracts should be considered unfunded. Those cases considered contract research to be funded unless:

  1. The payment was contingent on the success of the research, AND
  2. The contractor retained substantial rights in the research.

The contracts that the court reviewed were all fixed priced contracts, and all gave the client a right to review and approve design documents and dispute invoices (i.e., payment was shown to be contingent on the success of the research).

Additionally, the contracts did not contain provisions prohibiting Populous from using the research it performed, or require payment to the client for the use of the research (i.e., the contractor retained substantial rights in the research).

As a result, the court held that the research performed by Populous was not funded.

The Outcome

This case is significant in that it reinforces the current law surrounding the definition of funded research. As the IRS continues to look for new ways to limit the research credit, changing the requirements of funded research will not be one of them.

R&D & Energy for Real Estate Tax Accounting Methods

Construction and real estate firms often ask us: “How do we qualify for the R&D tax credit?” Our boilerplate answer is to review the 4-part test below to ensure you have a qualification marker that covers the activities you are performing to create or improve your products or processes.

By Brian Coddington, Max Vignola, Imran Syed | 15 Nov

New Small Firm Cost Seg Opportunities

Cost segregation is a highly beneficial and widely accepted tax compliance strategy utilized by commercial real estate owners and tenants to accelerate depreciation deductions, defer tax and improve cash flow.

By Brian Coddington | 12 April

Can the R&D Tax Credit Be Used to Offset the AMT?

The Protecting Americans from Tax Hikes (PATH) Act of 2015 includes provisions that allow certain taxpayers to offset their AMT liability with the R&D tax credit for taxable years beginning on or after Jan. 1, 2016.

By Alex Pak | 7 April

How the R&D Tax Credit Has Expanded Over the Years

Governments typically incentivize private industry to produce research and development (R&D) as a strategic tool to advance their economies.

By Deb Roth | 8 April

The Nine-Point Plan for Handling §179D

Section §179D can help your commercial real estate clients reduce taxable income and increase cash flow significantly.

By Source Advisors | 24 March

Reconciliation bill likely to have a tax impact on energy-efficient buildings

It’s no secret that climate change is a top priority for the current administration. As part of the hotly debated tax and spending legislation moving through Congress

By Source Advisors | 28 October

How Integrators Can Take Advantage of Incentives and Tax Savings

Integrators who have experienced a dip in business during the pandemic may be able to take advantage of a few lesser known tax credits and income tax deductions.

By Source Advisors | 11 August

Subscribe for our newsletter
to stay up to date
Email address

Related Articles